Tools

Is a new website worth the investment?

A website project pays for itself when the extra business it brings in covers what it costs. This calculator lets you test that with your own figures before you settle on a budget or an approach.

Work through the four sections in order, or jump to the one you need. Everything is calculated in your browser and nothing is sent anywhere.

01

Return on investment

Start from today's traffic and enquiries, then enter what you think could change. The starting figures are an example only. Replace them with your own.

Traffic and enquiries

From your analytics. Use a typical month, not the best one.

The rate after changes is your estimate, not a promise. Compare it with the break-even rate in the results to see how much improvement the project actually needs.

Out of every 100 enquiries, how many become paying customers.

Value of a sale

Typical revenue from one sale, or from the first year of a repeat customer.

Materials, staff time, fees and anything else spent to deliver that sale.

Project costs

Design, build and content for the new site.

Hosting, licences or support on top of what you pay today. Enter 0 if unchanged.

How long you expect the site to serve before it needs significant work.

Your time

What an hour of your time earns the business, or a staff cost.

Enquiries and sales per month

MeasureNowAfterChange
Enquiries
Paying customers

Customers = enquiries × . Not every enquiry is a sale.

Financial return

net return over , after the project cost
payback period
Additional revenue per year
Additional contribution per year, after direct costs
Extra running costs per year
Net cash benefit per year
Project cost
Return on investment over
Break-even enquiry rate

Contribution is revenue less direct costs, per sale. Monthly figures are annual ÷ 12. The break-even rate is the enquiry rate that recovers the project cost and running costs within the period. This return does not include the value of your time.

Time released

Hours released per month
Hours released per year
Value of that time per year
Net return over if that time is put to productive use

Time released is not a cash saving. It is valued at an hour, but only becomes money if the hours go to paid work, winning business or replacing paid help. That is why it is kept out of the financial return above.

    Cumulative cash position

    Month by month over , starting from the project cost. The dashed line adds the value of time released.

    Show these figures as a table
    02

    Compare approaches

    Four common ways to get a website, compared on what they cost over 3 years and the time they take from you. The figures are examples to show the trade-off. Replace them with quotes and prices you have.

    Your time is valued at the hourly figure from section 01. Cash and time are listed separately in the table, and stacked in the chart so you can see the full cost of each option.

    Your costs for each approach. All figures are editable.
    Approach Upfront cost (€) Running costs per year (€) Your hours per month
    Site builder, done yourselfA hosted builder such as Squarespace or Wix, set up and run by you.
    Template site, self-managedA theme-based site, often WordPress, where you look after updates, plugins and hosting.
    Custom build, you edit contentDesigned and built around your business, with a CMS you use for day-to-day changes.
    Custom build with ongoing supportAs above, with technical upkeep and agreed changes handled for you.

    Total cost of ownership over

    Upfront cost, running costs and the value of your time, per approach.

    This comparison leaves out conversion rates by platform on purpose. How well a site converts depends far more on the offer, the content and how it is built than on the platform it runs on. Use your own estimate in section 01 instead.

    03

    Which approach suits you

    Five questions about what the site needs to do, your budget, your time and how comfortable you are maintaining it. The recommendation updates as you answer.

    What does the site need to do?
    What budget is available for the project?
    How much time can you give the site each month?
    How comfortable are you looking after a website?
    How important is the site to winning work?

    Recommended approach

    Answer all five questions to see a recommendation.

    How the recommendation works

    1. Requirements set the floor. Bookings, payments and integrations rule out the lightest options sooner.
    2. Budget narrows the field to what is realistic.
    3. Time and comfort with maintenance decide who should look after the site once it is live.
    4. Importance to the business decides how much the site's performance can justify spending.

    Each answer adds weight to the approaches it suits. Where two approaches score the same, the less expensive one is recommended.

    04

    Full analysis and report

    Everything above in one place, ready to print or save as a PDF. The report always uses the figures currently entered on this page.

    Discuss your project

    In the print dialogue, choose "Save as PDF" as the destination to keep a copy.

    Summary

    net return over
    return on investment
    payback period
    break-even enquiry rate

    Inputs

    Results

    Enquiries and customers per month

    Show these figures as a table

    Net cash benefit per year at other traffic levels

    Show these figures as a table

    Approach comparison

    Recommended approach

    Points to check

      Assumptions and limits

      • All figures are estimates based on the inputs entered. They are not a forecast or a guarantee.
      • Paying customers are enquiries multiplied by the enquiry-to-sale rate.
      • Contribution is revenue less the direct costs of each sale. Overheads are not included.
      • Monthly figures are annual figures divided by 12. Traffic and rates are assumed steady across the period, with no growth or seasonality.
      • The financial return includes the project cost once and extra running costs every year. It does not include the value of time released, which is shown separately.
      • Approach costs are the figures entered in section 02, not quotes.

      Want a second opinion on the numbers?

      If you are weighing up a new site or a rebuild, tell me what you are trying to fix. I will say plainly whether a project is likely to pay for itself and what it would involve. Your results stay on this page unless you choose to include them in your enquiry.